Errors & questions and general comments
Page 16 & 269
There appear to be two identical records of Martha Irish #92 & 7778 born different dates but both married to Peleg Brownell #93 & 7779 both marriages are on the same date and year(4-15-1786). This seems quite odd to me.
Page 68 & 444
Ella Irish #1614 appears again as #13465 with different parents. Same birthday and death and m. - Vreeland.
Page 244
John Mack Irish #7022 and Dorthy Moore #7023 are reveled more in the Ca Birth records. Dorthy's last name is found and the births of most of the children and deaths of some. Also added Patricia Ann and Michelle Gay.
Page 270
Rowena Lucy Judson #7801 and Alma Judson #7808 appear to be sisters, since have same mother and father, but no mention is made of this relationship.
Are Oscar Edgerton #7822, Hiram Edgerton #7823 and Robert Edgerton #7827 all related? or is this just coincidence?
Page 272 & 273
Are Mary Sophia Irish #7863 & 7873 the same person married to Harvey W. Shaw #7864 & 7874 both died the same year (1922)
Page 277
Marie Stroble # 8063 b. March 1923 does not fit as a daughter of Dorthy M Irish #8033 as Dorthy was born 1920 and Marie was born 1923. Cannot find a place for her to fit in this family. Also book says Child for Richard J. Stroble #8062 rather than Children.
Page 286
There are other children from the marriage of John Woodard Bjork # 8346 and Verval Young # 8347 by the Ca birth records that fit the marriage dates. Need verify.
Page 290
Gerald Arthur Holloway appears on page as 8363 but should be 8463 which fits the page and that is how he is in the index.
Page 311
Mabel Bell Irish #8203 from page 282 should appear as first child of Noyes Irish #9103 & Maria Coleman #9104. She fits the marriage dates OK, but does not appear in book on page 311, and only appears in index as #8203. Josephus Hull Irish also only appears once in the index as 8202.
Page 318
Rexford Eugene Doctor # 9382 b. 7-4-1936 says he is a twin, but there are no other births with the same date. Could the child have been stillborn and not in the book? Odd since book gives others in other parts with no name at all.
Page 323
Thomas Alfred Ducro & Megan Jane Ducro appear as the same number #9542. This is not too odd as there are quite a few of those, but not usually displayed this way.
Page 324
Very bottom of page says "Other children were:..." Not sure children of whom? Edmund or Sivilla. I suspect Edmund as the column fits. Just unusual to enter this way without a number and breaking up the children this way where part have a number and part do not.
Page 328
# 9719 & page 360 #10772 book says same person but first name is spelled Smiton & Smyton
Page 329
Ralph A. Bicknell #9761 shows m. 11-1-1953 but believe it to be 11-1-1853 as it fits the marriage
Page 338
Chloe A. Irish has a + beside the number but does not appear as expanded as the + would indicate. But the family does appear on page 353, but not as a main family heading.
P346
#10296 Ada Viola (Oaks) Irish appears to be the same person as 10299 Ada Viola Oaks but birthdays are 1 year apart. No notice in the book as being the same person or being the wife of Louis Alonzo Irish.
Page 351
#10445 Lewis Eugene Irish second wife Josephine - m. 2-23-1946 has no number
Page 352
Believe the death record to be the correct Frank, but need to check. The birthday in the book is 4-5-1908 while ca records show 4-8-1908, an easy mistake for one to make.
Page 353
Who is Nash referring too for 10539
Page 354
Typo for Mala Marie Wood she appears on the page as 7485 but does not fit the numbers. She should be 7385 and that is how she appears in the index.
Gordon A Irish was in USN from 9-1929 to 6-1954 but do not have source.
Page 357
Are 10645 - Helen May Cormer & 10647 - Mary Cormier sisters?
Page 369
#11052 m date appears as 1050 a bit too early. Probably 1950 as it fits their birth dates.
Page 370
#11075 where is Howard Irish?
Page 386
11659 reference to 11956 should be ref to 11958
Page 370
Vernon Herman Klein #11074 m. Gloria Irish #11075 - These two appear on page 402 # 12221 & 12220 along with 3 of the children. The marriage date is the same. I do not think the book had actually linked these two entries up correctly. I use the name differences and the childrens birth dates for this opinion, but on the other side on page 370 Gloria Irish is not italicized which somewhat indicates they knew about her. Why they did not link up names and her father as Howard Arthur comes as a question, just as not having placed the birth dates for each as a cross reference. Also they do not show Gertrude with her maiden name as they do with others. It is so much easier to see with a computer... The 3 children's birth dates are off some but the years are the same. Why do the three children show twice with different numbers? Their common relative is Jessie5 but may not have even known they were related.
Page 411
#12431 Boyd Thompson Birthday shows 6-24-1950 but in ca records shows 6-24-1949
#12431, 12432, & 12433 all show born in different counties in CA, but in book all show in Marysville. Marysville is probably where they were living at the time, but not born there.
Page 424
Nathan Irish # 12839/12854 and Wealthy Irish #12840/12853 both show twice (good), but why do their children show twice? No big...Jus a little bit different than what they do normally with the +
Page 436
Hester Skeggs does not show as the daughter of #13194 Mary Irish and William Skeggs as is shown on page 371 #11144 Hester Skeggs.
General Notes:
Linc saw a page from one of Lafe's Granddaughters about still owning one of his violins, but cannot find the page. Still looking. Not sure if it was Lafe or not.
Fix death links to page 372
Page 424
12840 See Welthy Irish
Page 425
12892 See Florine Irish
Page 435
Links to establish
Page 436
Are #13199 Eunice Lobdell and 13208 Lydia Lobdell sisters?
Page 445
#13492 the second M(2) appears to be a duplicate of the first line
Look up 13479 in CA records
Page 449
Look up 13616 in CA records
Check page 469 #14217
Page 473
#14359 s/b 14269
Check page 494 or 3 Lucile Hanson in ref
Page 479
Jessie Irish @ wife Clarissa Flint have incorrect numbers. They should be 13732 & 13733. See page 455
The two numbers are already assigned, so this appears to just be a typo on this page.
Page 498
Frank L. Irish is #15074 not #15081 - Appears to be a typo
F. Josephine Harkness is #15075 not #15082 - Appears to be a typo